Surveillance and Workers' Compensation Cases
Sometimes there's more to a workers' compensation case than just showing the causal relationship between injury and employment activities. WIth the rising existence of technology in our lives comes the use of this technology to attempt to discount workers' compensation claims. Employers are starting to use surveillance and even materials from social networking sites as evidence against employees' claims for workers' compensation. Employers are claiming that their surveillance footage or social media materials show that particular employees are lying or blowing the injury out of proportion. As a result, employees have to be ready to explain every movement.
The good news, is that the Illinois Workers' Compensation Commission is willing to listen to all sides when technological evidence is presented. In a recent workers' compensation case, the employer presented video surveillance of the employee getting in and out of a vehicle, walking slowly, going into a store and lowering himself to retrieve something. The employer considered this evidence that the employee was magnifying his symptoms of low back and shoulder problems. However, the Commission found the surveillance to be innocuous and not contradictory to the employee's claims of disability and pain. As a result, the Commission awarded disability benefits for a total of 187 weeks.
Another case where the employer used surveillance footage involved a construction worker who was complaining of a work-related injury to his left wrist. The employer presented footage of the worker carrying a bucket in his left hand up a ladder. At first glance this seems like a devastating blow to the employee's workers' compensation case. However, if the employee can show that the bucket was in fact empty, his claim may be able to survive.
What does this mean for a new workers' compensation claim? If you have been injured at work and are concerned that your employer is going to use technological materials to try to discount your claim, do not worry. The Illinois Workers' Compensation Commission will listen to both sides of the story and your Illinois Work Injury Attorney can help you explain the situation. Sometimes, employees try to work through their injury because they are afraid of losing their job or due to loyalty to their employer; whatever the reason is, this should not prevent you from receiving the benefits you are due.
Sources:
Pratl v. Reserve Marine Terminals, 18 ILWCLB 70 (Ill. W.C. Comm. 2009)
Cyril Tuohy, Watching Your Step with Surveillance, Risk & Insurance Online, November 15, 2010.